JavaScript is off/unavailable on your browser. You will not be able to experience this website as it was intended without JavaScript enabled.
Yuan Shao’s court in his Ji Provincial capital of Yè City was condemned
to be a sombre place since his infamous historic defeat at Guandu. Tens of
thousands of soldiers had died, been captured or defected to Cao Cao’s Han
forces in the chaos that followed: in addition to that, Yuan had lost a large
number of talented advisers and officers.
At the start of the
campaign against Cao Cao’s regime in Xuchang City, Yuan Shao had enjoyed more
than just a numerical advantage: none but the most shrewd - and aware of Yuan’s
nature - would have expected the outcome. Firstly, Yuan had prestige and great
wealth: his ancestors had been trusted vassals in the Imperial court in
Luoyang, and one of his more influential ancestors, Yuan An, had the rare
honour of being commemorated with statues; Shao’s wealth was such that he could
simultaneously fight a 7-year campaign against his brother Yuan Shu and the
northern warlord Gongsun Zan and still have the financial security to launch an
immediate campaign against Cao Cao in the aftermath. Secondly, Yuan had one of
the largest pools of military talent: Generals Yan Liang, Wen Chou and Zhang Hè
were only outclassed by the likes of the prodigy Lü Bu; he had a Wuhuan cavalry
force that few could match after a serious famine five years earlier; and he
had dozens of advisers while others typically had a handful. Thirdly, he had a
strong list of third-party supporters: the itinerant warlord Liu Bei, Jing
Governor Liu Biao and the north-eastern Wuhuan tribes were publicly united behind
him, while the bandit kin Gong Du of Yu, the Yellow Turbans of Runan and a
faction of rebellious officials in the capital led by General of Chariots and
Cavalry Dong Cheng were silent partners and the southern warlord Sun Ce was
said to be considering his own march against Xuchang after deciding that Cao
Cao was a threat to his own vision for the south. Fourthly, Yuan Shao enjoyed
near-total control of Bing, Ji, Qing and Yòu Provinces and all the resources
that those provinces offered.
By contrast, Yuan Shao’s
opponent Cao Cao was on the defensive. Cao Cao had an army of only a quarter of
the size of Yuan’s that was tired after simultaneous campaigns against a rebel
faction of Southern Xiongnu warriors, the Yellow Turbans of Runan, the warlord
Lü Bu, Zang Ba’s Mount Tai Bandits and the pretender Yuan Shu. Further to that,
the capital Xuchang was surrounded on all sides, the construction of Xuchang’s
imperial palace and the restoration of Luoyang had drained the already-strained
treasury, and the Han enjoyed only limited control over Xu, Yu and Yan
Provinces. As a final, apparently deadly blow, Dong Cheng’s plotters were found
to be in possession of an imperial edict - the so-called ‘Girdle Edict’ - that
condemned Cao Cao as a traitor and called upon the nation to destroy him.
But from the beginning,
Yuan Shao was actually doomed: Cao Cao’s counsel provided sound advice that led
to the exposure of Dong Cheng’s conspiracy, enabling Cao to dismiss the edict
as a forgery and damage the campaign; Yuan Shao and his allies repeatedly
hesitated and failed to coordinate, allowing Cao Cao to make better use of his
limited resources and eliminate certain problems one at a time; Sun Ce was
assassinated - some said coincidentally, others suspected Cao’s involvement -
and Ce’s successor Sun Quan quickly made it clear that he would not march
against the capital; and Yuan’s large assembly of advisers quickly proved to be
more of a hindrance than a help as they conspired against each other to further
their own careers and offered contradictory advice that often led to crippling
defeats.